International
The Morning Dev

Only the news worth knowing

‹
 

Business2 sources233 comments in the community

Judge denies motion to dismiss DRAM price-fixing lawsuit against Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix, finds evidence of DRAM collusion plausible after 500% price surge

Tom's Hardware · By Jowi Morales ·

Judge denies motion to dismiss DRAM price-fixing lawsuit against Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix, finds evidence of DRAM collusion plausible after 500% price surge

The Brief · written from 2 sources

  • A judge denied the motion by Micron, Samsung and SK hynix to dismiss a proposed class action alleging DRAM price fixing.
  • The defendants argued the suit was a rerun of earlier claims, but the judge found evidence of collusion plausible given a reported 500% price surge.
  • The case continues past the motion to dismiss stage, and its outcome is not yet decided.

Why it matters

The case keeps alleged DRAM price fixing in litigation, so pricing evidence may surface that bears on memory costs for PC and server builds.

Who’s affected

  • PC and workstation builders facing higher RAM prices
  • Teams buying server memory and GPUs with large VRAM budgets

Judge Noël Wise, who presides over the proposed class-action lawsuit against Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix , has denied the companies’ motion to have the case dismissed. According to the decision , the defendants’ argument that the legal action is just “a rerun” of the same…

What developers are saying

Based on 233 comments · Mixed reactions

Commenters are largely hostile to the memory makers, with many calling the price rise obvious collusion and wanting stronger action. Skeptics argue that the shift to HBM and AI demand could explain the supply cut, and some note the complaint itself admits production moved to HBM.

  • Suspicion of collusion35%
  • HBM demand explanation20%
  • Consumer price impact25%
  • Calls for regulation15%

In favour

  • + Price surge and past collusion convictions make the claim plausible
  • + Concentrated market may not correct itself without intervention

Concerns

  • − Shift of capacity to HBM may explain reduced DRAM supply
  • − Complaint text reportedly undermines the collusion argument
  • − Fines would likely be passed on to customers

“It's the most obvious price fixing case in history”

dev1ycan on Hacker News

“It's a 3 way prisoners dilemma market where the prisoners have been caught explicitly colluding before.”

PeterStuer on Hacker News

“I read the original complaint in this case when it was filed and I think it's a nothing burger.”

nullc on Hacker News

Timeline

  1. Judge Noël Wise denies motion to dismiss the DRAM price-fixing class action

  2. Hacker News: Front Page

    Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case

  3. Hacker News

    527 points · 233 comments

  4. Latest from Tom's Hardware

    Judge denies motion to dismiss DRAM price-fixing lawsuit against Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix, finds evidence of DRAM collusion plausible after 500% price surge

Full coverage · 2 sources

How do you feel about this?

0 Comments