International
The Morning Dev

Only the news worth knowing

‹
 

Opinion184 comments in the community

"I can tell you wrote this yourself"

Lobsters ·

The Brief

  • A blog post titled "I can tell you wrote this yourself" argues that writing made without AI is worth valuing, and it was shared on Lobsters on 2026-11-20.
  • The post drew 191 points and 184 comments on Hacker News the same day, and 1 point with no comments on Lobsters.
  • Commenters mostly discuss whether AI use in writing is a crutch, a useful tool, or a sign of lost original thinking, and they disagree sharply.

Why it matters

The thread shows how developers are split on AI-assisted writing, and it highlights how readers may treat style and typos as signals of whether text was machine-generated.

Who’s affected

  • Developers who write reports, documentation or blog posts
  • Readers who judge whether text was written by AI
  • #ai-writing
  • #llms
  • #developer-culture
  • #education
  • #critical-thinking

What developers are saying

Based on 184 comments · Mixed reactions

Commenters largely agree that thinking for yourself matters and that over-reliance on AI is a concern, especially in education. Many, however, argue that AI is simply a tool that can be used well or badly, and some note that good writing can now look AI-generated. The thread also includes many jokes and light criticism of the post's own typos.

  • AI as a crutch25%
  • AI as a useful tool25%
  • Typos and mistakes15%
  • Education and assignments15%
  • Good writing mistaken for AI10%
  • Original thinking worth keeping10%

In favour

  • + Writing and thinking without AI keeps people able to reason independently
  • + Thinking for yourself is valuable, and it was always a minority habit
  • + AI can be a weak substitute for understanding and original structure

Concerns

  • − AI is a tool, and the problem is how people use it, not the tool itself
  • − AI can be a useful reviewer for grammar, spelling and structure
  • − Absolutist positions ignore that AI can handle boilerplate while people keep original thinking
  • − Demanding writing without AI may be bureaucratic and disconnected from real workflows

“I don’t get this knee-jerk association of AI = lies or wrong.”

alex43578 on Hacker News

“Because there is no excuse to present something riddled with mistakes an AI would have found in an instant.”

snvzz on Hacker News

“It is a compliment.”

jwrallie on Hacker News

Timeline

  1. Blog post published and shared on Lobsters and Hacker News

  2. Lobsters

    "I can tell you wrote this yourself"

  3. Lobsters

    1 points · 0 comments

  4. Hacker News

    191 points · 184 comments

How do you feel about this?

0 Comments