Opinion184 comments in the community
"I can tell you wrote this yourself"
Lobsters ·
The Brief
- A blog post titled "I can tell you wrote this yourself" argues that writing made without AI is worth valuing, and it was shared on Lobsters on 2026-11-20.
- The post drew 191 points and 184 comments on Hacker News the same day, and 1 point with no comments on Lobsters.
- Commenters mostly discuss whether AI use in writing is a crutch, a useful tool, or a sign of lost original thinking, and they disagree sharply.
Why it matters
The thread shows how developers are split on AI-assisted writing, and it highlights how readers may treat style and typos as signals of whether text was machine-generated.
Who’s affected
- Developers who write reports, documentation or blog posts
- Readers who judge whether text was written by AI
- #ai-writing
- #llms
- #developer-culture
- #education
- #critical-thinking
What developers are saying
Based on 184 comments · Mixed reactions
Commenters largely agree that thinking for yourself matters and that over-reliance on AI is a concern, especially in education. Many, however, argue that AI is simply a tool that can be used well or badly, and some note that good writing can now look AI-generated. The thread also includes many jokes and light criticism of the post's own typos.
- AI as a crutch25%
- AI as a useful tool25%
- Typos and mistakes15%
- Education and assignments15%
- Good writing mistaken for AI10%
- Original thinking worth keeping10%
In favour
- + Writing and thinking without AI keeps people able to reason independently
- + Thinking for yourself is valuable, and it was always a minority habit
- + AI can be a weak substitute for understanding and original structure
Concerns
- − AI is a tool, and the problem is how people use it, not the tool itself
- − AI can be a useful reviewer for grammar, spelling and structure
- − Absolutist positions ignore that AI can handle boilerplate while people keep original thinking
- − Demanding writing without AI may be bureaucratic and disconnected from real workflows
“I don’t get this knee-jerk association of AI = lies or wrong.”
“Because there is no excuse to present something riddled with mistakes an AI would have found in an instant.”
“It is a compliment.”