International
The Morning Dev

Only the news worth knowing

‹
 

Business200 comments in the community

Google is pushing OEMs against GrapheneOS and bootloader unlocking

Hacker News: Best ·

The Brief

  • GrapheneOS reports that Google is pressuring device makers (OEMs) against GrapheneOS and bootloader unlocking.
  • A commenter quoting the GrapheneOS thread says Google is repeatedly contacting OEMs to ask whether they work with GrapheneOS and threatening them.
  • Commenters note that Google is making some features and updates exclusive to Pixel devices, and that the report lacks detailed evidence.

Why it matters

If OEMs restrict bootloader unlocking or stop supporting alternative operating systems like GrapheneOS, developers and privacy-focused users lose choice over the software on their Android devices.

Who’s affected

  • Android users who want alternative operating systems such as GrapheneOS
  • Owners of Android devices who unlock bootloaders
  • Android OEM partners and their customers

What developers are saying

Based on 200 comments · Mostly critical

Commenters are mostly critical of Google, seeing the move as an attempt to lock down Android and restrict user choice. Several say it strengthens the case for GrapheneOS and for antitrust or EU action. Some doubt the report's evidence and criticize GrapheneOS's communication style.

  • Google locking down Android30%
  • Support for GrapheneOS25%
  • Antitrust and regulation15%
  • Bootloader unlocking is hard to stop10%
  • Criticism of GrapheneOS communication5%

In favour

  • + Google is a business, so the move can be read as a business decision to protect its ecosystem

Concerns

  • − Vendors should not decide what users can do with their own devices
  • − Possible anti-competitive behaviour that antitrust law should address
  • − Pixel-exclusive features and pressure on OEM partners harm the wider Android ecosystem
  • − The report lacks detailed evidence, which makes it look like ragebait marketing

“I'm sick and tired of vendors deciding what the users are and aren't allowed to do with their own devices.”

ACCount39 on Hacker News

“Google should not be allowed to control android.”

mzhaase on Hacker News

“My 10a will be the last Pixel I buy if the bootloader of future editions can't be unlocked.”

drnick1 on Hacker News

Timeline

  1. GrapheneOS publicly reports Google pressuring OEMs against GrapheneOS and bootloader unlocking

  2. Hacker News: Best

    Google is pushing OEMs against GrapheneOS and bootloader unlocking

  3. Hacker News

    498 points · 200 comments

How do you feel about this?

0 Comments